Illegal Arrest and Detention of Australian

April 16, 2018
Karapatan decries the illegal arrest and detention of Sr. Patricia “Pat” Fox, NDS, a missionary of the international Roman Catholic congregation of women Sisters of Our Lady of Sion, from the Congregacion de Notre Dame de Sion (Congregation of Our Lady of Sion).

Sr. Pat, 71, is an Australian citizen who holds a missionary visa in the Philippines since the 1990’s and is conducting community service as part of her missionary work in the country. An advocate of genuine agrarian reform and human rights, Sr. Fox has joined activities of the Unyon ng mga Manggagawa sa Agrikultura (UMA) and Pagkakaisa para sa Tunay na Repormang Agraryo (PATRIA), including recent international fact finding and solidarity missions in Mindanao that looked into the impact of the Duterte regime’s martial law and counterinsurgency program Oplan Kapayapaan on poor peasants in the island. Sr. Pat is also a consistent and untiring advocate of the rights of agricultural workers, including the farmworkers in Hacienda Luisita, and that of indigenous peoples, including the Lumad.

At around 2:30pm today, April 16, six intelligence officers of the Bureau of Immigration went to Sr. Pat’s house in Project 3, Quezon City. The BI agents “invited” her for random checking and verification of her immigration papers and status. They hurriedly showed her an “invitation/mission order” but they did not give her a copy. Fox asked the agents if she can go to the BI office the next day, but they told her that she should go with them now and that she was not allowed to defer her “visit” to the BI office. Sensing that she had no choice, she went with the BI agents, accompanied by a fellow nun from her congregation.

It was only when they arrived at the BI office in Intramuros, Manila at 4pm today, when she was read of her Miranda rights. BI officers did not show any document indicating charges against Fox. Her captors, though, have been saying that she is being arrested for joining rallies and “illegal political activities,” that she will be detained overnight and that she will be deported tomorrow. As of this writing, inquest proceedings against Fox are ongoing.

In February 2018, five foreign members of an international solidarity mission were also held by the Bureau of Immigration in General Santos City. The International Coalition for Human Rights in the Philippines and the Mindanaoans for Civil Liberties spearheaded the said mission to investigate reports of human rights violations in Mindanao linked to the implementation of martial law and counterinsurgency program Oplan Kapayapaan.

Last April 15, Italian citizen Giacomo Filibeck, Deputy Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists, was barred from entering the Philippines and was immediately deported by BI officials from the Mactan-Cebu International Airport. Filibeck was part of an international human rights mission in October 2017 in the Philippines that looked into cases of human rights violations.

Also, in a speech last April 13, President Rodrigo Duterte warned Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda of the International Criminal Court that she will be barred from entering the country and will face arrest as the ICC pursues its investigation on Duterte’s accountability in the extrajudicial killings in line with the drug war.

“The Duterte regime’s contempt for any and all forms of investigation, including that of international human rights observers and development workers, into its record of human rights violations betrays its guilt. If indeed Duterte is as innocent as his sycophants say, there would be no reason for blocking any form of independent inquiries into the cases of extrajudicial killings and other rights violations against peasants and other poor sectors in the Philippines. Given the illegal arrest and detention of Fox, as well as the many documented cases of threats and harassment against delegates to fact-finding missions in the Philippines, it is clear that Duterte has much to hide and is guilty as hell on these rights violations,” said Karapatan Secretary General Cristina Palabay.

“The arrest of Fox, as well as the other forms of threats against human rights advocates from the international community, are clear and blatant forms of violation on the exercise of people’s right to extend international solidarity to victims of rights violations. Fox is deprived of her right to due process, to information on why she is being arrested and to direct access to human rights organizations and legal counsels. She has been serving peasant communities in the country for decades, and thus her missionary work is true to the values of genuine community service,” Palabay added.

“Fox should be immediately released and her deportation should be vigorously opposed. It is an irony that the Duterte regime and those who are threatening Fox’s deportation are the very people who have made the country a living hell for its citizens, while foreign missionaries and rights advocates like Fox have long been working side by side with the poor and oppressed to improve their deplorable conditions,” Palabay concluded.

Reference: Cristina Palabay, Secretary General, ‪0917-3162831‬
Karapatan Public Information Desk, ‪0918-9790580‬


Hands Off Human Rights Defenders!
Free Sr. Patricia Fox!


Photo by Ronalyn Olea of Bulatlat of Sr. Patricia Fox


Photos by Maria Sol Taule

BI frees Aussie nun amid protests


MANILA – The 71-year old Australian missionary Sister Patricia Fox was released for further investigation by the Bureau of Immigration (BI) today, April 17, a day after she was taken into custody on Monday.

Fox was detained inside the agency’s office in Intramuros, Manila.

Sister Patricia Fox after her release from the Bureau of Immigration, April 17. (Photo courtesy of Sinag Bayan)

Before her release, several groups expressed condemnation over what they described as the arbitrary arrest and detention of the Australian nun who has been in the Philippines for the past 27 years. Groups led by Kilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP) held an indignation rally in front of the BI saying that helping the poor and the oppressed is not a crime.

“The government could not present any apparent logical reason for Sister Pat’s arrest and detention. State forces just want to threaten, harass and intimidate foreigners and Filipinos who would stand up against state-sponsored killings and terrorism,” said KMP secretary general Antonio Flores.

Read: Immigration agents arrest Aussie nun active in human rights work in the Philippines

Other progressives and colleagues from the church such as Sr. Mary John Mananzan, former Bayan Muna Rep. Satur Ocampo and Bayan Muna Rep. Carlos Zarate also went to the BI office to visit Fox and wait for her release.

Reports said that Immigration Commissioner Jaime Morente has approved the recommendation of the BI legal division to release Fox “after it was established that the Australian nun holds a valid missionary visa and, thus she is a properly documented alien.” The BI said that Fox submitted her passport and other immigration documents which showed that her visa is valid until September 9 of this year.

The BI arrested Fox over intelligence reports of her participation in rallies and other political activities including the recently held International Fact Finding Mission in Mindanao.

Furthermore, the BI legal division also noted that “while Fox was alleged to have taken part in protest actions by farmers in the past, she was not doing so at the time when BI operatives served her the mission order.”

At past 3:00 p.m. Fox was finally released from the BI’s custody and was warmly welcomed by the groups who called for her immediate release.
Cristina Palabay, Karapatan secretary general said Fox’s “release is a result of the concerted efforts of the religious, peasant activists, human rights advocates, lawyers, progressive legislators and all who believe that activism is never a crime.”